If Lisa J. Damon has a bridge to sell, I’m buying it. And, it’s not because I’m all that gullible. However, over the course of one hour she changed me from an admitted Lean Six Sigma skeptic into a person willing to consider the possibilities of that approach for every law firm. I had previously heard several presentations on the law firm miracle that is Seyfarth Lean Six Sigma, but it was only when Ms. Damon and Seyfarth’s Chief Information Officer, David Hambourger, explained how they and their colleagues are beginning to change the way the lawyers of their firm actually practice law that I began to appreciate the scope of their accomplishment.
First a little background, Six Sigma is a business technique developed by Motorola to quickly identify and fix defects in its manufacturing processes. Lean is a business technique derived from the Toyota Production System to redesign a manufacturing process to make it more balanced and consistent, thereby removing waste from the system. (Another way of looking at this is to eliminate anything that does not create value for the end customer.)
At first blush, neither approach to manufacturing would have much obvious application to the work of any lawyer who considers herself or himself to be an artiste. Even in a so-called “law factory,” I’m not sure many would consider lawyers to be in the manufacturing business. However, Seyfarth’s leadership came to the conclusion that elements of their practice needed to be handled with the same discipline Motorola and Toyota brought to manufacturing.
What drove them to this conclusion? Economics. As their clients started requesting more alternative fee arrangements, Seyfarth’s leadership correctly concluded that the firm would take a loss unless it could find a way to reduce its own costs of production. So six years ago they began with the following goals:
- improve predictability of fees
- lower client costs
- increase transparency
- allow clients to collaborate
- provide clients with real-time access to fees and the management of a matter
After looking at pure Six Sigma and Lean, and talking to clients who had used these approaches, Seyfarth settled on a modified Lean Six Sigma approach tailored for legal services. To begin with, they eliminated the jargon, some of the statistical tools and the heavy-duty math. (Ms. Damon acknowledges that the focus on numbers demanded by Six Sigma would have been a major turn-off for every lawyer in the firm who went to law school just to avoid another math class.) They also built in some strategy, project management and change management. Along with this, they hired client-facing professional project managers and created a project management office. The other key element is a commitment to continuous, sustained improvement (kaizen) in the quality of the services they deliver.
To make these wholesale changes in the way they practiced law, the lawyers of Seyfarth also had to make wholesale changes in the way they carried out the business of law:
- They replaced their professional development and promotion model with a more dynamic model based on advancement by competency and achievement rather than tenure.
- They replaced their compensation model so that it rewarded results achieved rather than time spent.
- Seyfarth has a scorecard system based on the ACC value index. They survey clients and then reflect that response in partner compensation.
- They moved from merely automating manual processes to the creative, strategic use of knowledge, expertise and operational information.
- They changed their service model from bill/pay as you go to one with a more strategic focus, with defined outcomes based on client business goals.
Lisa Damon is honest about the work involved in making such extensive changes within her firm. While they don’t yet have 100% adoption, she says they make a new convert every day. Along the way, they take every opportunity to improve their practice and their business. As the inimitable Ms. Damon put it, “Seyfarth loves to process map. We create process maps for anything that moves within the firm.” In addition, they approach this in a way that flattens the hierarchy within the firm; everyone with expertise is brought into the effort — whether they are professional project managers, paralegals, secretaries or lawyers. In the beginning, they create their process maps with paper and pen. Later, they record their process maps using a lawyer-friendly tool called Task Map (an overlay to Visio). Once the process maps are created, they are linked to key knowledge management tools such as case analysis, checklists and samples. Better still, each process map can be tailored to the needs of individual clients or matters.
On the IT and knowledge management side, Dave Hambourger reports that they started by implementing enterprise search. They also have built extranets that create new business for the firm. (They are not just inert document repositories). Another important element is the way they have deployed SharePoint to deliver “memorable value” to clients. This includes matter management tools and financial dashboards. The matter management tools show both the percentage of the project completed as well as the percentage of the budget spent. Since the dashboards are visible to the clients, the lawyers of the firm have had to learn the discipline of entering their time daily.
Lisa Damon will be the first to tell you that none of this has been easy or cheap. However, the sheer joy with which she tells the Seyfarth Success Story suggests that the undertaking has been well worth the effort. At the end of the day, sustaining a success story like this requires top-level business support, careful project selection, project discipline, and a focus on continuous improvement. Seyfarth shows that it can be done. Is your firm willing to try?
If you’d like to learn more about SeyfarthLean, I’d encourage you to read (or listen to) the following:
- Law and Order (iSix Sigma Magazine) — see also the Seyfarth press release on this article
- Lean Six Sigma Tools, courtesy of Seyfarth Shaw’s Lisa Damon (Rees Morrison)
- Making it Lean (ABA Journal)
- Raising the Bar: How Seyfarth Shaw Provides Efficient Delivery of Legal Services Through Lean Six Sigma — and see also the Seyfarth press release on this podcast
- SeyfarthLean: A Commitment to Deliver Quality and Measurable Results (Seyfarth)
- SeyfarthLean Background (Seyfarth)
- Value Practice: Use of Tailored Six Sigma Methodologies at Seyfarth Shaw (ACC)